Roof Repair_shutterstock

Roof Repair vs. Replacement: What to Consider

When deciding between roof repair vs. replacement, there are many factors to consider. These options have pros and cons. Ultimately, the decision will depend on your situation and budget. At Allied Construction, we have expert roofers who know that roof repair ensures your roofing system’s integrity. However, damage can be irreparable or cost more than you would spend on a new roof. Therefore, our experts may recommend roof replacement instead of repair.

But what do we consider to recommend roof repair or replacement? After many years in the industry, our roofers have acquired extensive hands-on experience. Also, they are familiar with different roofing systems and their pros and cons. Therefore, they have what it takes to recommend and provide the most appropriate solution to roofing problems. Here’s what they recommend you consider when deciding between roof repair vs. replacement.

Residential Roofing

Roof Repair vs. Replacement: Roof's Condition

The condition of your roof is an essential factor to consider when deciding between roof repair vs. replacement. If the damage is minimal, you can fix it without replacing the entire roof. However, if several faults cost more to repair than replace, a complete roof replacement would be more suitable and cost-effective in the long run.

Some roof problems we can repair include broken or missing shingles, loose flashing, faulty gutters, and damaged downspouts. On the other hand, extensive damage, such as sagging roof decking and water damage, may require a complete roof replacement.

Age of the Roof

The age of your roof is another factor to consider when deciding between repair vs. replacement. Generally, if a roof is over 20 years old, you should opt for a complete roof replacement. That’s because roofs have a lifespan and start to deteriorate after about two decades due to exposure to weather elements such as rain, snow, wind, and extreme temperatures. Also, older roofs are more prone to structural problems that experts can’t solve with simple repairs.

Roofs become brittle and more prone to damage from storms or winds when they age. Therefore, our experts may recommend replacing the entire system instead of patching the damage. Repairing an old roof will cost you more since the issues you fix will keep reoccurring. 


Costs are another factor we consider before recommending a roof repair or replacement. Roof repair and replacements have different costs. The cost of repairing a roof can vary depending on the problem’s severity and complexity. Replacing an entire roofing system will cost significantly more because experts must remove all materials and replace them as necessary. Also, they must dispose of waste from the old roofing system properly.

Therefore, consider these options and their associated costs before repairing or replacing your roof. Calling Allied Construction to request a free roof repair or replacement estimate is the best approach. That’s because you’ll know how much repairing or replacing the roof will cost and compare before deciding what to do.

Allied-Home Page Header Contact

Future Plans

Also, consider your plans before deciding between roof repair and replacement. If you plan on selling the house soon, replacing the roof may be a better option since it adds value to the home. A new roof will attract more potential buyers and help you fetch a higher price. On the other hand, if you plan on staying for a while, then repairs are enough to keep the structure in excellent condition. However, this depends on the state of your roofing system because replacing it may be the most cost-effective solution if it will cost you more to be in better shape.

Your Roofing Material

The material that makes up your roofing system is also a factor to consider when deciding between repair and replacement. Different materials have different lifespans, so you must assess whether it’s time for a replacement. For instance, asphalt shingles generally last between 15-30 years, while metal can last about fifty years. Therefore, if the existing material has aged beyond its expected life expectancy, you should opt for a complete replacement instead of just repairing some areas.

Energy Efficiency

Also, consider the energy efficiency of your roofing system. Older roofs are less efficient in trapping heat and cooling a house during summer. Replacing an old roof with modern materials will help you save on energy consumption by regulating indoor temperatures better. Therefore, a total roof replacement could be a great choice if you want your home to be more energy-efficient and eco-friendly.

Roof Repair shutterstock

Roof Repair vs. Replacement: Aesthetics

The appearance of your roof is also an essential consideration. If you’re planning to sell your home soon, a new roof may add to its overall appeal and resale value. However, repairs may be a more practical solution if you’re not concerned about aesthetics.

Local Climate

The local climate in your area can also play a role in your decision. If you live in a place with frequent severe weather, such as hail, heavy rain, or high winds, a new roof may be more durable and better able to withstand the elements.

Insurance Coverage

If your roof has sustained damage due to a covered event, such as a storm or falling debris, your insurance company may cover its repair or replacement. Check with your home insurance provider to determine your coverage and whether it makes more sense to repair or replace your roof.


Safety is always a top priority when it comes to your roof. If your roof is severely damaged and poses a safety risk, it’s best to replace it as soon as possible to avoid further property damage or injury.

Ultimately, you may not have a definitive answer as to whether you should repair or replace your roof since every situation is unique. But with our help, we can evaluate your roof and give you the best advice on what you need to do to get a maximum return on investment. Remember, deciding between roof repair vs. replacement is vital and careful consideration to ensure your safety and that of your property. Call Allied Construction for professional help with this decision.